Rail safety: luck is not a control measure

Insight from Chris Morgan

In my last column, I raised a slightly uncomfortable question about the stories we tell ourselves in the rail sector. We love to benchmark against our immediate peers, pat ourselves on the back, and lean heavily on a very specific assumption: that while air travel failures are catastrophic, rail failures rarely are.

Recent events in Spain, and closer to home at Bedford, have shattered that comfortable illusion in the worst possible way.

When catastrophic incidents happen on modern European and UK networks, it forces every single one of us in the industry to stop and think. First and foremost, my thoughts are with the families, the injured, and the frontline responders dealing with the aftermath of both tragedies. Once the dust settles, though, we owe it to those affected, and to the millions of passengers and workers who rely on our networks every day, to take a long, hard look in the mirror.

For years, we have worked under a quiet assumption that our safety margins are wide enough, and that our operational safeguards will always catch a cascading failure before it turns fatal on a massive scale. We look at our rolling stock, our signalling, and our rulebooks, and we feel relatively secure.

Here is the trap, though. Just because we haven’t had a catastrophe recently doesn’t mean we are safe.

Let’s go back to that comparison I brought up last month, looking specifically at commercial passenger air travel. Why does commercial passenger aviation hold onto such an extraordinary safety record despite operating in a far more hostile physical environment? It isn’t because their technology never fails, and it certainly isn’t because pilots don’t make mistakes. It is because the industry is structurally paranoid and operates with a genuine culture of chronic unease.

In commercial passenger air travel, a near miss, whether it is a minor deviation in altitude, a misheard radio call, or a tiny maintenance oversight, gets treated with the exact same forensic urgency as a major crash. They don’t wait for the worst case scenario to happen before they overhaul a system. They actively hunt for warning signs, knowing that if you allow enough minor failures to line up, the holes in the Swiss cheese will eventually align.

Now, compare that to how we behave in rail. Take Signals Passed at Danger (SPADs), near misses with trackside workers, or minor infrastructure defects. Because these things happen with a worrying regularity, we have become completely numb to them. They have turned into background noise. Instead of treating a SPAD as a vital piece of intelligence that the system is flashing at us, we treat it as a routine operational headache. We investigate, we find the immediate human error, we put out a safety briefing, and we move on, feeling quietly relieved that “nobody got hurt.”

We treat luck as a control measure.

The tragedies in Spain and Bedford are a stark reminder that high energy systems do not forgive complacency. Modern trains move at huge speeds, carrying hundreds of people, governed by complex interfaces between drivers, signallers, digital systems, and physical infrastructure. When those interfaces break down, the consequences are every bit as unforgiving as an incident at 35,000 feet.

We cannot afford to ignore the warning signs right in front of us. We need to stop measuring our safety performance by how many days it has been since our last major accident, and start measuring it by how aggressively we find and fix the small things when nobody gets hurt.

If we only ever look at lagging indicators, we won’t see the cliff edge until we’ve already gone over it.

What are the warning signs in your part of the railway that we’ve simply grown numb to? I’d genuinely like to know.

Related News

LNER leads ORR passenger assistance rankings as requests rise 18%

London North Eastern Railway has ranked highest in the Office of Rail and Road’s latest passenger assistance assessment, as requests for support across Britain...

RSSB introduces common standards for battery trains and charging systems

RSSB has published a new standard for battery-powered trains, giving manufacturers and operators a common set of requirements for battery systems and charging equipment...

Midlands Rail Hub explores Digbeth improvements after public feedback

The Midlands Rail Hub Alliance is examining improvements to streets and spaces around its proposed Bordesley Viaduct extension after consultation raised concerns about the...

Featured Partners

Randstad Solutions Limited

Business Support

MPI Ltd

Related Articles