Can GBR deliver a better industrial relations strategy?

Insight from Richard Lungmuss

Coming from a military background my only knowledge of the rail unions when I joined Railtrack / Network Rail had been gleaned from the media, so in my mind they were prone to striking and frequently airing various grievances.

When I joined Kent Route in 2003 as an Infrastructure Maintenance Manager I soon found myself sitting down opposite my RMT counterparts as we consulted the new organisation that brought maintenance in house. Later, as Maintenance Director for Scotland I frequently met the senior RMT reps in Scotland to discuss a number of issues, including safety, discipline and working conditions.

My perceptions had now met reality with the actual union staff responsible for their members. The first thing to say is that my perceptions changed markedly. In Kent I was faced with experienced railmen who knew far more than I did about the actual work and working conditions their members worked under. They offered highly constructive suggestions for the new organisation, many of which were accepted unequivocally. [Our working relationship was helped too by mutual support of Chelsea from at least one senior RMT member!] Later in Scotland I was faced by some very “serious” and experienced characters, who made it clear that they would be pretty intransigent when it came to their members. My perceptions were further affected when we had a very serious safety incident and I wanted to discipline those involved, highly senior track staff, and the union rep offered me his full support. He told me that my emphasis on workforce safety in Scotland was appreciated and was the RMT’s highest priority too. [Those in question in this incident were dismissed and took Network Rail to a tribunal, where they did not win reinstatement] My perception thereafter was, and is, of the unions as a force for good, if allowed to be.

The RMT has around 80 – 83,500 members in the UK, with the drivers’ union ASLEF having a further 23,000. Between 2011 and 2026 around 2 million working days were lost to strikes, the majority between 2022 and 2024 during the National Rail dispute. Indeed between Jun 2022 and Dec 2023 1.95 million working days were lost resulting in a 5% reduction in services in 2023 and a 3% reduction in services in 2024. The causes for the dispute are well known and include: the lengthy pay freeze, high inflation, proposed changes to working conditions and job cuts. Potential pay rises were linked to modernisation of working conditions, changes to Sunday working, shift patterns etc. The major problem was attempts by some TOCs to implement Driver Only Operation (DOO) with loss of guards. This latter issue was, and still is, fiercely resisted by the unions.

Eventually the RMT accepted a deal with NR and 14 x TOCs, and with a change of government ASLEF accepted an unconditional backdated 3 year deal. The additional overall cost was £135m to the 2024/25 budget, which can be offset against the cost to UK businesses and commuters:

  • Direct impact £1Bn
  • Lost revenue £850m
  • £4-5Bn estimated losses to the hospitality industry
  • UK GDP 0.5% lower
  • £2Bn in lost economic output

Put in stark numbers it is perhaps surprising that the dispute wasn’t settled sooner but in the fragmented privatised industry it felt like “every person for themselves” when it came to negotiating with the unions and the DfT certainly appeared to sit on their hands. [I was once part of a team evaluating a franchise bid and part of the rationale for pricing was that this particular TOC were very confident in their industrial relations strategy and felt they could quickly come to an agreement on DOO. They priced the reduction in staff accordingly, which may have been partially why they won the bid. Their subsequent industrial relations issues cost them dearly and they received no help from the centre as both performance and revenue plummeted during disputes!]

I have previously mentioned how there are now more, not less, signallers following the rationalising of signal boxes into Rail Operations Centres and this is another example of savings assumptions that aren’t realised due to industrial relations. Network Rail is forever re-organising and usually in doing so they try to remove layers of middle management staff as a “cost saving and efficiency” measure. We have all seen these staff leave the business, only to turn up in a couple of weeks working for a consultant or a contractor, costing more per day than previously but coming out of a different pot of budgetary money – is that really saving the industry and UK PLC money?

With the formation of GBR there is an opportunity to reset industrial relations and for the rail industry as a whole to come together. I welcome the formation of the Rail Engagement Group which will include GBR/ DfTO/TUC/RMT/ASLEF/TSSA and UNITE members and I believe there is a definite willingness to incorporate frontline staff input into operational decisions.  GBR has a real opportunity to “think differently” regarding an industrial relations strategy. I believe they should really listen to what the unions want for their members. I also believe that a lot of what the unions want is also what paying customers want. Whilst this might cost more up front in terms of headcount and terms and conditions, everyone working on the railway is paying taxes (and drivers will know all too well where the 40% tax threshold starts!), people working on the railway are NOT on welfare and even more importantly they are contributing to a flourishing Rail pension scheme that will help keep them off welfare in later life. [Don’t forget it was the rail unions that ensured that the Final Salary Rail Pension was not diluted or removed back in the early 2000s and the far sighted decision to offer it to everyone completing 5 years in the industry promoted stability and loyalty]

The unions remain unwilling to embrace efficiency and productivity initiatives that cut jobs and they continue to reject self-funded pay deals and voluntary redundancy. I believe that it is now time for the Government and GBR to embrace the unions’ views far more fully and to consult much more closely about the benefits (such as reliability and overall performance) that technology and innovation can bring to the industry when deployed in the right place. The unions also feel that there is far too much outsourcing and agency spending in the industry (see above) and would like to see long term workforce planning and more apprenticeships. Why not embrace that view and take a far more holistic view of the rail industry inside wider government spending? With all the emphasis on NEETs at present surely the rail industry is an ideal place for our young people to be starting work?

Passengers (customers) also like having staff on trains and at stations and no amount of technology can replace the human interface.

I know that people reading this opinion piece are going to point at the loss of productivity since 2014/15 amid a 19% higher headcount. Maybe that is the point that GBR should be grasping?, the fact that the rail industry is a major employer in the UK, those working within it have a shared purpose and can be brought into a “one team” organisation in GBR, even if there are more heads in the organisation than the bean counters would like? (call it “inefficient working!”) The unions offer a different, and more human, perspective as to how this might be done and I commend them for their persistence and sheer “bloody mindedness” for achieving on behalf of their members over the past few years. Now that profits will not be going abroad, or to shareholders, maybe time to open the books too so the unions can have a say in how the money is being spent? After all without their members there is no rail industry. Hard as well to sit across the table discussing with the unions when Network Rail senior staff numbers and salaries have been outstripping the average over the past 10 years.

Related News

Rail safety: luck is not a control measure

Insight from Chris Morgan In my last column, I raised a slightly uncomfortable question about the stories we tell ourselves in the rail sector. We...

LNER leads ORR passenger assistance rankings as requests rise 18%

London North Eastern Railway has ranked highest in the Office of Rail and Road’s latest passenger assistance assessment, as requests for support across Britain...

RSSB introduces common standards for battery trains and charging systems

RSSB has published a new standard for battery-powered trains, giving manufacturers and operators a common set of requirements for battery systems and charging equipment...

Featured Partners

Randstad Solutions Limited

Business Support

MPI Ltd

Related Articles